Is it possible for Clay Helton to win back the faith of USC fans in 2020? The Trojan fanbase is not interested in anything less than a championship, Pac-12 or national.
The return of Clay Helton as USC head coach was met with disappointment, if not anger, from the USC fanbase at large.
But has he lost the fans for good? What would it take for Helton to get the fanbase back on his side?
CHECK OUT: OT Joey Wright decommits from USC
Short answer: A lot.
Longer answer: Winning big is a must in 2020.
What would it take for Clay Helton to change your mind about him as #USC head coach in 2020?
— Alicia de Artola (@PenguinOfTroy) December 5, 2019
Simply put, fans expect Helton to put up or shut up. For the majority of respondents in a very unofficial Twitter poll, nearly 50 percent, that means winning a playoff game. Another third of voters put the threshold even higher: Winning a national title. Less than 20 percent saw winning the Pac-12 as adequate.
But of course it’s not that simple. Not just because Twitter polls are unscientific, but because USC fans have a vast array of opinions on what it would take for Helton to win them over as individuals.
For some, a Pac-12 title would go a long way to putting them at peace over Helton’s return, though doing so in impressive fashion is part of that scenario.
assuming that winning the Pac-12 means they're in or on the bubble of the CFP (5/6), that should be adequate.
— Doug Drozd (@dougqdrozd) December 5, 2019
Undefeated in the pac12. Top 10 in the final college football playoff rankings.
— AB (@alex_burchinal) December 5, 2019
Everyone needs to pump the breaks and look at the really great teams that have made the playoffs and not won. I think winning the pac 12 is sufficient. Either way I’m a Trojan #fighton or #fightontomediocrity
— mini traveler ✌️ (@Bert_B1989) December 5, 2019
For many others, a playoff berth is the start, with additional concerns focused on recovering USC’s recruiting ranking.
The Trojans are currently ranked 78th nationally and 11th in the Pac-12 in the 247Sports composite. That’s a historically low ranking for one of the biggest recruiting powers in the west.
I would even entertain "making a playoff game"
— Sara (@SCTrojan42) December 5, 2019
He would have to pull out a top 20 class this off season, and atleast make the playoffs next year for me to give him a CHANCE. One miraculous season won’t do it which is why I say give him a chance https://t.co/9nrgSVNbKj
— RIP Mamba (@Trojan_boy05) December 5, 2019
CFP or bust. We’ve done the conference and the Rose Bowl deal. Also in a non wins and losses situation I want to see him create a tougher team in general.
— Q Been Eatin (@BDQuom) December 5, 2019
Playoff games...not too much to ask
— John Stevens (@johnnyste_) December 5, 2019
Reaching the CFP Championship game.
— Grant (@grant3young) December 5, 2019
As for the playoff itself, that would be a step Helton hasn’t yet taken as a head coach. Since fans have seen him win a Rose Bowl and take the Pac-12 crown before, it’ll take more to convince them the head coach has the team on an upward trajectory.
What else are fans looking for when it comes to Helton proving them wrong?
A change to USC’s practice strategy is one thing…
Can you add “Practice Tackling after August” to the Poll?
— Blake Eastman (@Beastman_Crunch) December 5, 2019
Also, beating Nick Saban’s Alabama when the Trojans square off with them in Arlington in September of 2020 would go a long way…
Beat Bama by 30. That wont ever happen with him as coach so...
— Just A Fan (@JustAFa21469728) December 5, 2019
Many USC fans are willing to give Helton a chance in 2020, but a chunk have no interest in waiting any longer for Helton to win them over.
Nothing. I vote for nothing
— Sweet Jones, lil bitch (@KingJrJones) December 5, 2019
Nothing
— tim (@tim93603048) December 5, 2019
Add a choice of Nothing and I will vote
— Mitch Stein (@MitchStein6666) December 5, 2019
Resigning before spring camp, signing a top tier coach, giving Harrell enough $ to stay, replacing DC & STC, staying on to do recruiting and administrative work on behalf of SC.
— DLH (@HawaiiPunMom) December 5, 2019
None of the above. What it would take for me would be him having class like Peterson and stepping down before the spring. Then he’d get my respect back as a person but not as a coach. Let’s face it UNLV probably wouldn’t hire him as a HC.
— bsenaha (@uschicali) December 5, 2019
Those fans appear to be lost causes for Helton.
The 2020 season will have plenty of intrigue and no one knows how it will all play out in the end. A weak Pac-12, with Utah replacing the core of their South division-winning team, Stanford and Washington slipping and question marks swirling over UCLA and ASU, and a relatively favorable schedule should put USC in the running for the Pac-12 title. That’s if Helton can get his team prepared to take advantage of the slate in front of them.
That is, and will remain, the big question.
So what would a fair standard to hold Helton to?
The skepticism around the head coach has always revolved around his ability to take USC to the top. So playing Alabama competitively, whether winning or losing, is a reasonable start. Winning a weak Pac-12 is unquestionably legitimate. Getting to the Pac-12 title game would be an absolute minimum. Avoiding any embarrassing blowout losses in general is not asking too much. From there, again it’s all about how far Helton is capable of bringing his team.
Boil that all down? It’s time for USC, and Helton, to start winning the eye test.