The news that North Carolina escaped NCAA punishment for academic fraud sent USC Football Twitter into a rage on Friday.
On Friday the NCAA concluded that North Carolina did not commit infractions relating to their academic fraud scandal and USC Twitter was not happy about it at all.
The Tar Heels have been under investigation going back three years, not quite as long as the four-year investigation into USC, but close. At the heart of the investigation: Was UNC’s athletic department responsible for funneling student-athletes to sham classes arranged by the African-American Studies department from 1993-2011?
Short answer? No.
Here’s the NCAA’s explanation:
Committee on Infractions could not conclude North Carolina violated NCAA rules: https://t.co/iPE127Txqr pic.twitter.com/suI59ucHvs
— NCAA (@NCAA) October 13, 2017
Committee chief hearing officer Greg Sankey explains the decision further. pic.twitter.com/MjknFZnRiz
— NCAA (@NCAA) October 13, 2017
Essentially, North Carolina argued that the athletics department played no role in the academic deficiencies of the African-American Studies department. Since the classes, which were disproportionately filled with athletes, were available to the general student body at UNC, no violations occurred.
And the NCAA agreed. Or at the very least, failed to find a loophole in their own rules to properly punish North Carolina’s own use of a loophole in the rulebook, deferring to schools to determine what does and doesn’t count as academic fraud.
Unsurprisingly, Twitter as a whole and USC Twitter, in particular, took umbrage with the ruling. After all, the Trojans only just finished sanctions relating to the Reggie Bush scandal. The Heisman Trophy-winning running back and his family received benefits from a would-be agent and USC was hit with a two-year bowl ban and loss of 30 scholarships over three years.
The NCAA told the Trojans they “should have known” about the Bush family’s rent-free living in San Diego, 150 miles away. The NCAA told North Carolina that they had no responsibility for knowing about classes
not
being held on their campus.
Here’s how Twitter reacted to the news:
— Joey Kaufman (@joeyrkaufman) October 13, 2017
The NCAA is a joke.
— Saman Djabbari (@samandjabbari) October 13, 2017
(Unrelated, but the @NCAA's decisions continue to be a high-level cosmic joke.)
— TravelerHatesThurs (@THT_USC) October 13, 2017
Committee on Infractions "could not conclude" that violations were committed by UNC. Eighteen years of academic fraud gets a pass.
— Pat Forde (@ByPatForde) October 13, 2017
Announce that UNC did nothing wrong before most USC fans are awake. pic.twitter.com/QargddKktQ
— Mike Perez (@MikePerez24) October 13, 2017
USC after the NCAA gave no punishment to UNC for academic fraud. I mean... fake classes.....errrrr... "athlete friendly classes." #FightOn✌️ pic.twitter.com/DowT0LMcOk
— SoullessTrojan (@Rodneyinthe626) October 13, 2017
Can Reggie Bush come back to USC then
— kenneth (@KennethMartin7) October 13, 2017
NCAA Math: USC punishment > PSU + Miami + UNC + Ohio State + FSU + Baylor punishments combined
— Ryan Roberts (@startuplawyer) October 13, 2017
Wrong on so many levels, how do you have the gall to Tweet this? ? So UNC is Robin Hood and that's ok? https://t.co/q2Q4pBK2QO
— USCarlos (@uscarlos) October 13, 2017
#NCAA removed sanctions on Penn State re worst scandal in history. Can't say I'm surprised at the UNC thing. Guessing USC is a bit peeved
— Tim Roesler (@TimRoesler) October 13, 2017
The #NCAA is so upset with UNC that they've concluded that L'ville and USC must be punished. ?
— Tim Roesler (@TimRoesler) October 13, 2017
As a USC Trojan, whose athletics program suffered for YEARS from bogus NCAA decisions, this is infuriating! #FightOn
— Heather Curtis (@holiwood98) October 13, 2017
This proves the NCAA is a fraud institution. Give @USC_Athletics their national championship back. https://t.co/l1lFSX8ure
— Jeremy Diaz (@jeremyalandiaz) October 13, 2017
As a USC fan, every time I finally get over the NCAA screwing over USC, things like this happen and I get pissed all over again!
— Jess Arriola (@socali18) October 13, 2017
With sanctions over and no hope of getting anything back for them, all USC fans can hang their hat on is the ongoing lawsuit by former assistant Todd McNair against the NCAA. The question is, how many more schools will see infractions reports come and go before that matter is resolved?